- Gabriel Jesus' deflected 53rd minute goal the difference between the two sides at Stamford Bridge
- Manchester City dominate the match as Chelsea fail to get a single shot on target
- Defeat for Chelsea is their first of this campaign
First a victory over the European champions and now to Paris to take on the club that thinks it should be European champions, although for Manchester City up and running once again one would not rule out victory on Tuesday over the crowded superstar collective at Parc des Princes.
They have inflicted the first defeat on Chelsea since that warm night in Porto in May when Thomas Tuchel’s team rolled with the punches and then picked off City in the second half to win the Champions League. On that occasion Pep Guardiola tried to create his masterpiece but in doing so neglected to select a defensive midfielder. Four months on, this should have been a great game between two of the three best teams in the league. Instead it was one-sided and insipid for large parts.
Guardiola’s team had six starters from the final, although crucially among the other five was Rodri, an orthodox holding midfielder who was himself on this occasion outshone by a new candidate in the deep-lying position, the outstanding Bernardo Silva. For 76 minutes, until Fernandinho came on and Bernardo was edged into a more advanced position, the Portuguese international controlled that critical part of the pitch and in doing so permitted City to control the game.
Control it they did, restricting Chelsea to the grand total of zero attempts on target. The decisive goal itself, struck on the turn by Gabriel Jesus and taking an enormous deflected turn off Jorginho was not their cleanest strike but it was one of five, out of 15 that were on target. The mood was that it was coming from somewhere, with Jack Grealish on the left wearing away Cesar Azpilicueta, asked to patrol that wing after the first half injury to Reece James forced his withdrawal.
“When we win the manager is a genius,” Guardiola replied with his customary pseudo-gloom to the question about his selection. He poured praise on Tuchel, the manager who had beaten him on three occasions before now, but on this afternoon was a long way from that standard. City dominated the game and they did so without the conventional centre-forward. This time it was Phil Foden who was asked to do the old No 9 conjuring act against a three-man defence, while the real pressure came down the sides from Grealish and Jesus.
This was a Chelsea performance that never truly commenced. Mateo Kovacic lost the midfield in the first half, while Romelu Lukaku was never in the game. N’golo Kante was substituted in the first hour. Antonio Rudiger tried to pick the occasional argument and then late in the match Fernandinho, on as a substitute, made sure that the Chelsea man had something to remember the game by. Hard not to think of the German’s part in his collision with Kevin De Bruyne in the final in May as he picked himself off the turf.
Tuchel would be heavily critical of his side afterwards, wondering whether they “lacked belief and confidence” to escape the positions that City put them in. “With every mistake we lost more and more confidence,” he said. “We defended very well in the box and in the goal but of course it was too deep.” He said that “part of any performance is to make the opponent under-perform.” “This is what City did to us,” he said. “They were strong and sharp with better positions.”
As City embark for their first Champions League collision with Paris Saint Germain, so the defending champions play Juventus in Turin on Wednesday with much to think about for their manager. They have not looked as vulnerable as they did on this occasion for some time. It certainly seemed that Tuchel had once again decided that they could afford to have less of the ball and use Lukaku and Werner on the counterattack. “When we reached Romelu the attack was already half over,” Tuchel said, “and there was simply no belief or connection”.
This victory took Guardiola to 221 wins for his Manchester City career, unsurprisingly he now has the most of any manager in the club’s history. He surpasses Les McDowall, the India-born son of a Scottish missionary, who was in charge for the post-war years when Sir Matt Busby’s Manchester United were resurgent and under McDowall City still managed to win an FA Cup in 1956. McDowall’s thoughts on the deployment of defensive midfielders in major finals may have been lost in time, but his successor seems to have changed his view on the best way to beat this Chelsea team.
Guardiola stuck to a familiar tone after the game, maintaining that his side will always pursue a purity of purpose in the hope that results will follow. “For me the way we play, the courage and the personality, we have never lost [in that respect] from the first day we were here.” Certainly there was no doubting City’s purpose in taking control of this game which they dominated until the late stages when the home team had no alternative but to push forward for the equaliser.
The Jesus goal was created when Rodri’s shot was stopped by his team-mate on the edge of the box and Jesus manoeuvred enough space for him to shoot through a crowd of legs. It looked like the touch off Jorginho was the one that deceived Edouard Mendy although it should never have been an option for the City man to find the room to shoot.
There were other chances, the best from Grealish who edged his way into the box on 58 minutes, drawing Azpilicueta into a small misjudgment and then seeing his shot pushed just wide by Mendy. The loss of James to a twisted ankle in the first half meant that Chelsea’s captain was given the job of trying to corral Grealish down the left wing and there was no love lost between the two. By the time Grealish was replaced by Raheem Sterling with a few minutes left you could see by the smile on his face that he had done his job.
Tuchel made changes to no avail, first Kai Havertz and then that great homegrown lost soul Ruben Loftus-Cheek, on for Jorginho with around 15 minutes to play. Both sides were stacked with talent on the benches but Tuchel must have seen something in Loftus-Cheek’s performances in training to send him on ahead of the likes of Callum Hudson-Odoi and Hakim Ziyech. There were a couple of nice carries with the ball but when the final whistle blew, the embarrassment for Chelsea is that they were still waiting for their first decent chance.  Â